PTP vs. PCB

For some time now gearheads have debated the merits of PTP (point to point) wiring versus PCB (printed circuit board) in amplifiers. The benefits of each as well as the shortcomings are the source of many a heated argument.

Much of this information or mis-information comes from amplifier manufacturers themselves. Many production amplifier companies will tout how consistent the PCB method is as well as the ability to produce amplifiers at a price point many can afford. Many Boutique companies will tell you PTP is the only way to the tonal Valhalla you are searching for.

It is a fact that repairs on a PTP amplifier are often easier to perform because everything is easy to access and there is little concern over damaging the circuit board. PTP also allows for inconsistencies in even in the same model amplifier.

PCB offers a lot of bang for the buck. It also allows for hefty repairs. PCB amps can often be hard to work on and if the board itself is damaged, it may be rendered worthless.

So who is right? Who is telling the truth? What are the facts? Well I’ve found a few articles that talk about the facts. The first article is from the Bogner Amplification website. It is actually written by Andy Marshall of THD electronics. This man certainly knows his stuff. The second article is by Randal Smith of Mesa/boogie. This man is no slouch either.

I don’t favor one over the other, in fact, I own a PTP amp as well as a PCB amp. They are both very good sounding amps and very reliable. I love both equally and play both equally. My only preference in an amp is that it sounds good and it’s reliable.

Scott

Share this post :